Summary

When discussing educational issues, people often overlook the efforts and challenges of educators such as teachers, which is also a key part of promoting quality education. Three articles by Oberg, Álvarez, and Walker approach this issue from different perspectives by focusing on compassion fatigue and teacher guilt. While the articles introduce different points, the emphasis in each is that teachers are strained in their profession and systemic changes are urgently needed to help with their mental health. This analysis compares themes, tones, and examples present in these articles to explore how each deals with the emotional load on teachers.

Image source: HtcHnm from Pixabay

Analysis

As reports show, children with trauma and mental health issues have taken up an increasing proportion of classrooms. Helping them can leave a physical, emotional, and psychological impact on the educators, as the process causes emotional exhaustion, and the failed attempts reduce the sense of personal accomplishment. This has raised concerns that the mental health of teachers is also worth paying attention to.

Oberg (2024) describes the emotional burden placed upon Australian teachers who are experiencing compassion fatigue, where the wear and tear of empathizing with students’ needs has negatively impacted their lives and performance. Álvarez (2024) addresses “teacher guilt,” where a teacher often feels they are never doing enough, leading to burnout. Therefore, perfectionism needs to be abandoned. Walker (2023) looks into the broader issue of compassion fatigue in education and its draining effect brought on by continuous empathy for students’ traumas and needs.

Around different central ideas, the tones in the three articles vary. Oberg’s article is written in an empathetic and urgent tone about the true devastation this condition wreaks on a teacher’s personal and professional life. Álvarez’s article takes up a more reassuring and motivating tone. Teachers are urged not to feel guilty but rather seek their own good. Walker’s article is reflective and cautionary in presenting some first-hand accounts of educators depleting emotionally and shows how taking care of the self relates to the future of education.

The tones are also related to the authors’ attitudes. Oberg conveys an understanding and concerned approach, emphasizing the destructive role played by compassion fatigue both in teaching individuals and in the entire educational system. Álvarez has a supportive attitude for the teachers to be strong and to remember that they are more than a feeling of guilt. Walker presents a concerned yet practical attitude to the issue of compassion fatigue experienced by educators, appealing for systems change.

To support their opinions, they choose different proofs. As a PhD candidate, Oberg conducts her research and provides supporting data more academically.

“I found 73.9% of respondents had moderate-to-high levels of burnout when compared to the general population, while 71.5% were exhibiting signs of secondary traumatic stress. These results align with findings from other research. For example, a 2024 study on Victorian teachers reported similar rates.”

The paragraph above shows the reliability of the article as all conclusions are drawn from data and studies. Álvarez introduces both stories of teachers and analysis of experts in the article. The improvements of teachers and suggestions from specialists call on teacher empowerment by reminding them of their value beyond guilt. Walker mainly focuses on the experience of Manganaro, supported by related surveys and analysis. He also reviews the history of compassion fatigue to elaborate on the definition.

Personally speaking, I agree with all the authors, especially that the emotional challenges is a community-related and systematic issue that we should deal with. Though the articles have different aspects, they all emphasize the importance of self-care, support systems, and a shift in societal views about the emotional labor involved in teaching. I believe that such issues need to be addressed as important for teachers’ well-being, but also for the benefit of the whole educational system.

Sources:

[1] Oberg, G. (November 28, 2024). ‘I am exhausted’: Australian teachers speak about how compassion fatigue is harming them and their work. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/i-am-exhausted-australian-teachers-speak-about-how-compassion-fatigue-is-harming-them-and-their-work-244519

[2] Álvarez, B. (November 15, 2024). Say Goodbye to Teacher Guilt. NEA Today. https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/teacher-guilt

[3] Walker, T. (December 8, 2023). ‘My Empathy Felt Drained’: Educators Struggle With Compassion Fatigue. NEA Today. https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/compassion-fatigue-teachers